There is no perfect grant cycle. Based on our experience speaking with hundreds of rejected applicants and reviewing their proposals, we have devised this list of suggestions for funders who are looking to improve their funding programs.
Put Yourselves in the Shoes of Your Applicants
Fill out your own application. Read your own RFP. If you know that many of your applicants are applying to another funder, look at that funder’s RFP as well. Another way to gain a more empathetic view of the process is to evaluate proposals with Unfunded List. You can provide your own useful perspective to our authors while learning about other funding programs.
Time Your Declination Notices
Grantmaking cycles often take many months, which means applicants can wait a long time just to be declined. If you can, provide rejection notices in real time as you rule out applications. The sooner you let applicants know they were not selected, the sooner they can make other plans.
Give Specifics to Shortlisted Applicants
When there is a very clear reason that an organization did not advance, you should let them know that reason if possible. This is especially true if the proposal was submitted by a legitimate organization that simply misunderstood your criteria. Perhaps you fund crisis centers in Arkansas and a crisis center from Oklahoma applies. Tell them directly that they were rejected for that reason. Providing details to shortlisted applicants can help improve their future applications and eventually you will have fewer proposals to shortlist each round and higher quality submissions overall.
Use Degrees of Separation
For a myriad of reasons, the people who make the grant decision should not speak directly to rejected applicants. This is very unlikely to be productive and extremely likely to be awkward. Someone familiar with the application and decision-making processes, like a program officer or administrator, can have a more focused and objective discussion.
Get To Know Funders Outside Your Zone (as well as inside)
Maintain relationships with funders who fund the same issue or in the same location as you, but also with funders from adjacent areas. For instance, if Oklahomans are applying to your Arkansas-only program then it could be very impactful for the sector if your foundation built relationships with funders in Oklahoma.
Tell Your Story
Create content around your process like podcast episodes, blog posts, and even videos. Diligent grant proposal authors will do their research before applying. If all you show them is a scant website and RFP, that is all they can look at. Highlighting your winning grantees allows potential applicants to understand what you value. Produce podcast episodes or blog posts about common reasons for rejection and applicants can do their best to avoid those errors. The process of content creation could be valuable for your own thought process as well.
Recommend Unfunded List in your Rejection Notices
Consider including this paragraph:
We regret that we are not able to follow up with each submission individually and we recognize that feedback and review benefits proposal authors. Unfunded List is a nonprofit that provides independent review to grant proposals. We recommend submitting this draft to Unfunded List, a nonprofit dedicated to providing feedback to grant proposal authors. It will only take a few moments and you will receive feedback from several independent reviewers. Afterwards, you’ll have the opportunity to discuss the feedback you received and brainstorm next steps with one of Unfunded List’s proposal experts.
Let us know your suggestions for funders.
Do you agree with these? Disagree? Do you have your own suggestions for funders? Email your comments to dave@unfundedlist.com.

