Skip to content

Now Reviewing Your Proposals…

Unfunded List for Grantmakers

We enjoy working in partnership with thoughtful funders to enhance their grantmaking programs. 

We realize that the priorities and practices at funding organizations are unique and so we tailor our partnerships to the specific needs and timelines of each grantmaker. 

This page includes information about some of our past and current partnerships as well as a grantmaker interest form for funders interested in pursuing a partnership with Unfunded List.

Grant Proposals Can Be A Mess

Keeping track of numerous submissions requires a ton of administrative work. The prospect of choosing the best proposal can seem daunting to philanthropists who value inclusion and do not want to waste anyone’s time. 

Unfunded List lessens the administrative burden of a grant proposal process while providing valuable educational opportunities for both grantmakers and grantseekers. Fundraising organizations want to be able to submit proposals, but they also want feedback if they are rejected.  Unfunded List’s evaluation committee will independently review any proposal whose author requests it. You can focus on your grantees and programs assured that every applicant will receive value and no one will feel ignored. Since 2015, we have reviewed over 1,000 proposals and can review proposals on any topic, from anywhere in the world, submitted to any funder.  To conduct reviews we use our own custom software and rely on a committee made up of hundreds of volunteer grant proposal evaluators including experienced fundraisers and grantmakers. After the review, we share helpful feedback with our grantmaker partners as well. 

Most programs that involve high-level writing like PhD dissertation defense or submissions to academic journals involve similar organized review processes that benefit the sector as a whole. We know it works with grant proposals as well. According to a recent impact study we conducted, groups that we reviewed in 2016 were raising an average of 213% more funding by 2020.

For less than the cost of one of your average grants you can provide this kind of value to your own unfunded list. 

Why Co-Reviewing Applicants Creates a More Inclusive Philanthropic Field

All grantmakers face the same dilemma: there are more proposals than there are resources available. Some of the larger foundations might receive over 30,000 applications in a year, but will only actively fund four or five thousand programs. While unfunded applicants are commonly told to seek feedback, funders rarely actually provide it, due to resource strain or a well-meaning desire to not waste their applicant’s time.programs that are actively being funded.

Empowering Grant Applicants in the Oral Health Sector

The DTA Foundation and the Unfunded List Announce Partnership to Empower Grant Applicants in the Oral Health Sector. The DTA Foundation, a nonprofit committed to advancing oral health access and education, and the Unfunded List, a nonprofit focused on philanthropy education are teaming up to empower grant applicants in the field of oral health.

FAQS for Grantmakers

Co-review is when the Unfunded List Evaluation Committee partners with a grant maker to offer our review to every applicant. Grantmakers focus on making granting decisions and our committee focuses on giving feedback to every applicant.

During co-review with Unfunded List, a funder that receives submissions conducts their process as they normally would. They search for the next great solutions, award funds, and support the winning grantees. Meanwhile, Unfunded List focuses their support on everyone else who applied. Each organization receives one of our helpful and candid feedback reports including reviews from multiple evaluators as well as the opportunity to have a report discussion with Unfunded List Staff.

Our independent evaluation committee offers our review to all of the applicants of our partner program. Once a group opts in, we do not choose winners, but instead we provide helpful and candid feedback and suggestions for everyone, along with recommendations and feedback for the grantmaker after we are done.

Unfunded List is a 501c3 not-for-profit founded in 2015. Our mission is to educate the public about philanthropy which we do by engaging our learning community in the regular review of grant proposals. Working with grantmakers on co-review allows us to develop the reviewing skills of our evaluation committee while providing useful and candid feedback to proposal authors. We have conducted co-review partnerships with SOLVE at MIT, The Elevate Prize, Kettering Family Foundation, Circle for Justice Innovations Fund, Mentor Capital Network, Next Gen Giving Circle, Dental Trade Alliance Foundation, KujaLink and several others.

All kinds. We have over 1000 evaluators in our pool from all walks of life. We offer regular training sessions in philanthropy and make ourselves evaluators for conversations and zoom calls with our evaluators during their review. We encourage our evaluators to rely on their own experience and perspectives.

The professional grant writers on our committee will comment on things like formatting, phrasing, funder fit, and impact metrics. Issue experts will focus on impact and implementation as well as the accuracy of claims. Editors tend to focus on spelling and grammar. Social entrepreneurs and founders offer advice from a peer perspective while our more senior, retired evaluators focus on mentorship and advice. Some of our funders consider proposals for their own philanthropy and the connectors on our committee think about who to apply to next. We do our best to include a multitude of perspectives in each report.

We have been co-reviewing for over three years now, but this is a newer (and exciting) aspect. As we evaluate a large batch of proposals all submitted to the same grantmaker, certain trends and comments begin to emerge. For instance, during our first year co-reviewing with The Elevate Prize, a large number of our evaluators noted in their review that the proposal was very long and that some of the questions were repetitive. We passed these notes along to The Elevate Prize staff and they shortened and focussed their application for the second year of their prize. When we co-reviewed with Kettering Family Foundation our evaluators noticed some confusing language in the RFP and had questions about geographic location. We were able to pass these notes on to Trustees and administrators at Kettering who are now discussing ways to address our comments.

As we continue to co-review with these groups, particularly with groups who are willing and able to make changes to their philanthropic process, we can continue to be helpful in guiding those changes.

We partner with grant makers in ways that can benefit their programs but when we do it is always and primarily in service of our mission to educate the public about philanthropy. The primary ways we partner with grantmakers are to conduct co-review partnerships and to produce content related to philanthropy education.

In particular, we do not provide wealth or fund management services, fundraising or resource development services (beyond proposal review), we do not fiscally sponsor and we do not provide PR or marketing services, nor legal nor accounting services. 

Partner with us!

We have reviewed proposals with a variety of different grant makers including prize competitions, family foundations, large universities, international platforms, and giving circles both big and small. With our vast committee of evaluators we are confident that we can adapt to any funder.

Fill out this form to start the conversation